Pocket-Monkey(tm) Discussion Forum

[Home] | [Forum Games] | A question to get your teeth into[Forum Rules] [Login]

A question to get your teeth into

Thread #1621 - Messages: 22   (some may be hidden) **This thread is closed** 
 A question to get your teeth into Message #16129    Replies: 2
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 01/15 at 08:02
What happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object?
 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16131    Replies: 1
posted by Redbee (Lori) on 01/15 at 13:57
Since these are extremes that cannot be achieved due to the laws of physics, it cannot happen. However, If it could happen, I suspect a paradox would occur
 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16136    Replies: 1
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 01/15 at 16:07
It is an empirical question, not theoretical.
 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16140    Replies: 1
posted by Redbee (Lori) on 01/15 at 18:28
But it cant happen, so either way there is no correct answer
 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16150    Replies: 1
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 01/16 at 14:10
keep thinking,something does happen.
 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16154    Replies: 1
posted by anna716 (Anna) on 01/16 at 22:12
standoff? :>)
 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16175    Replies: 1
posted by Purplerose (Rose P.) on 01/20 at 18:54
The unstoppable force would just divert from the unmovable like a ball bouncing off of a wall.
 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16176    Replies: 0
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 01/20 at 19:47
Nope
 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16194    Replies: 1
posted by BennyHill (David) on 01/25 at 03:27
the closest thing to an unstoppable force today would be a black hole. If you believe in the big bang theory, the earliest moments of the universe would be an unstoppable force, as well. In both examples, an immovable object; I'm assuming it is made of atoms and such would be ripped apart at the atomic and subatomic levels which in all essence would turn the solid into various forms of energy which in turn become part of the unstoppable force. Sort of like what happens in the Atom smashers that physicists like to play with. Unless the assumptions are changed that I described above then the force would win out and move onto the next obstacle in its path. Have a GREAT day...


 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16195    Replies: 1
posted by magic (dot) on 01/25 at 08:12
the unstopable force would go around or over the top
 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16197    Replies: 1
posted by BennyHill (David) on 01/26 at 02:56
if it was deflected, the vector forces pushing it forward would be zero therefore not making it an unstoppable force. Good try... I'll keep the light on
 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16227    Replies: 1
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 02/01 at 11:41
I`m thoroughly enjoying this lol
 Re: A question to get your teeth into Message #16298    Replies: 0
posted by paully (Paul) on 02/27 at 17:04
The Irresistible force paradox, also the unstoppable force paradox, is a classic paradox formulated as "What happens when an irresistible force meets an immovable object?" This paradox is a form of the omnipotence paradox, but that paradox is most often discussed in the context of God's omnipotence ("Can God create a stone so heavy it cannot be lifted, not even by God Himself?").

The paradox should be understood as an exercise in logic, not as the postulation of a possible reality. According to modern scientific understanding, no force is completely irresistible, and there are no immovable objects and cannot be any, as even a minuscule force will cause a slight acceleration on an object of any mass. An immovable object would have to have an inertia that was infinite, and therefore infinite mass. Such an object would collapse under its own gravity and create a singularity. An unstoppable force would require infinite energy, which does not exist in a finite universe.

An example of this paradox in non-western thought can be found in the origin of the Chinese word for paradox (Chinese; pinyin: máodùn; literally "Spear-Shield"). This term originates from a story in the 3rd century BC philosophical book Han Feizi. In the story, a man was trying to sell a spear and a shield. When asked how good his spear was, he said that his spear could pierce any shield. Then, when asked how good his shield was, he said that it could defend from all spear attacks. Then one person asked him what would happen if he were to take his spear to strike his shield; the seller could not answer. This led to the idiom of "zìxīang máodùn", or "self-contradictory".
 'A question to get your teeth into' Message #16301    Replies: 1
posted by steelerfan1 (Jonathan) on 02/28 at 21:16
An EXPLOSION
 Re: 'A question to get your teeth into' Message #16340    Replies: 1
posted by magic (dot) on 03/18 at 19:45
ok gogdog, have you an answers to this question
 Re: 'A question to get your teeth into' Message #16341    Replies: 1
posted by judybell (judy s :O)) on 03/18 at 22:31
he might not..
 Re: 'A question to get your teeth into' Message #16342    Replies: 1
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 03/20 at 07:36
He might so.
 Re: 'A question to get your teeth into' Message #16343    Replies: 1
posted by judybell (judy s :O)) on 03/20 at 20:39
well like the person said what is the answer
 Re: 'A question to get your teeth into' Message #16345    Replies: 1
posted by magic (dot) on 03/21 at 21:26
like the unstoppable and the unmovable , its unanswerable lol
 Re: 'A question to get your teeth into' Message #16349    Replies: 1
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 03/22 at 08:41
Simple , the unstoppable force stops, the immovable object moves.
 Re: 'A question to get your teeth into' Message #18496    Replies: 1
posted by playBunny (pB) on 01/24 at 09:21
That makes no sense because it contradicts the essential properties of both entities.

A better answer is that the unstoppable force keeps exerting itself on the immovable object, which doesn't move.

A person standing on the surface of a planet is being pulled towards the center by an unstoppable force, namely gravity. But they don't necessarily have to move towards the center, they can stay where they are, unmoved, as long as something else exerts a force in the opposite direction. This is usually the planet itself. That doesn't stop gravity but it does stop any acceleration that might otherwise be caused by the gravity. Thus, the unstoppable force keeps on exerting itself and the immovable object remains unmoved.

The temptation with "unstoppable force, immovable object" is to imagine it wrong. If you think of, for instance, a bulldozer approaching a really huge boulder then it's easy to imagine the velocity of the bulldozer as representing its force. When the bulldozer meets the boulder you imagine it maintaining its velocity as a representation of unstoppability. Of course this means the immovable object moves which it can't. So then you change the image to the boulder remaining still while the bulldozer grinds to a halt. This, because your metaphor equates velocity and force, is equally impossible.

But this is not the case. When the bulldozer meets the boulder its velocity reduces to zero but the force does not. The bulldozer digs in and starts to churn up the earth. Purplerose and magic said above that the force gets redirected, and so it does. Nothing in the problem statement says that the force has a constant vector.

paully's Wikipedia quote puts it better. An irresistible force is not the same, strictly speaking, as an unstoppable force (and, in a question such as this you ought to be strict).

If you depict the force as irresistible then what you're saying is that something under it's influence cannot be immovable. Having put it that way ... woohoo!carry on, you got yourself a paradox!

(One for which I have no answer, heh heh) ;-)
 Re: 'A question to get your teeth into' Message #18497    Replies: 0
posted by playBunny (pB) on 01/24 at 09:24
ps. The natural inclination with a problem such as this is to imagine physical foces and objects. Here's a different image..
A complete chocoholic vows not to move from where they are. Nothing can sway them because they are totally, 100% resolute.

Then you place a chocolate cake in their field of view...
Hey presto, an immovable object and an irresistible force! ;o)

And doesn't this make it much more 'A question to get your teeth into'? ;-)

Forum software by Crowder Software
Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.