A man is locked in a room,it has two doors.One door leads to certain death the other to freedom.Each door has an armed guard and they know which door is which.One guard always lies,the the other is truthful.The man can ask ONLY ONE question of one guard to achieve freedom,what is the question?
Guard, what would the other guard say if I asked him where his door leads?
Here's the reasoning: Because whatever the reply is, the opposite will always be true. Example, let’s say the door behind the 1st Guard leads to freedom. If teh 1st guard is a liar, then he will lie and say that 2nd guard would say his door leads to freedom. If, however, the 1st guard is the truth-teller then he will report that the 2nd gaurd would say his door leads to freedom; and in this case the 1st guard is faithfully reporting the fact that the 2nd gaurd will lie. Either way you have the same answer, and the opposite will always be true. In both cases the liar is involved in the answer and the answer is always false.
posted by Silverwalker (Silverwalker) on 05/03 at 22:17
I like that problem!
The more common way of telling it goes this way, though:
"You come to a fork in the road, where only one direction leads to town. There is a house on either side of the road, and you know that two brothers live here; one brother is known for always telling the truth, and the other is known for always lying. But you don't know which brother is which. Which question should you ask one of the brothers to learn which road to take to town?"
Forum
software by
Crowder Software Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.