Pocket-Monkey(tm) Discussion Forum

[Home] | [Games : Chess] | Keep running Chess tourneys?[Forum Rules] [Login]

Keep running Chess tourneys?

Thread #2233 - Messages: 11   (some may be hidden)
 Keep running Chess tourneys? Message #23482    Replies: 9
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 06/01 at 07:11
Hi folks,

The Pocket-Monkey Chess game has a couple of serious issues, not least the fact pawns disappear sometimes (when the game mistakenly thinks an en passant capture should have happened). Given that we can't fix these bugs for the foreseeable future, and can't restore pawns that disappear, and the fact two players using the non-Java games can't have a draw, should we stop running new Chess tourneys?

Thanks in advance,
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey
 
 Re: Keep running Chess tourneys? Message #23483    Replies: 1
posted by niloc (Colin Palmer) on 06/01 at 08:05
I love playing chess, but as you not be able to fix those issue's I do think that you should stop running any new chess tourneys.
   
 Re: Keep running Chess tourneys? Message #23487    Replies: 0
posted by lcclick (Larry) on 06/01 at 12:31
hello,first i would like to say i dont play chess and if i did-i'd get killed...so
if u cant fix it...make it a feature..
the chancy en passant variation...
its up to the players if they want to take the chance...
 
 Re: Keep running Chess tourneys? Message #23484    Replies: 0
posted by rastaro (Ro Fernando) on 06/01 at 10:43
I agree that if there are bugs in the game then the tourneys should be discontinued for now
 
 Re: Keep running Chess tourneys? Message #23485    Replies: 0
posted by petr.pavel (Petr 'PePa' Pavel) on 06/01 at 11:15
I use the Java version and I did notice that I'm allowed to perform an en passant capture when I shouldn't. But apart from that, I haven't encountered any issues. When I lose, it's due to my incapability, not because of bugs :-)

What would be the point of preventing everyone from playing chess tournaments? To protect them from disappointment? Then let's put a warning on the tourneys page. Following the same suit, there should be a warning on the open invites page too.

I'm always wary about over-protection. Adults are given information and they make their own decisions. Children need protection.
 
 Re: Keep running Chess tourneys? Message #23486    Replies: 0
posted by playBunny (pB) on 06/01 at 12:31
There are numerous instance where adults with good information make incorrect decisions and there are laws that protect them. The compulsory motorcycle helmet law is one example that I particularly didn't like when it was imposed upon me however I'm still here and one of my helmets is not. ;o) The seat belt law is the equivalent for road-cattle (motorbikes being the free-riding cowboys amongst the herd, or maybe that's just my fantasy. ;o).

Laws such as those attempt to balance the loss of convenience for everyone against the prevention of harm to some. So Petr and I could debate the need for them but that's definitely for another forum and another (indefinitely rain-checked) day.

But I agree with him about it applying here. I think it's about the balance between the loss of Chess and the harm of people being affected by the bugs.

TJ, although the bugs are serious in terms of the game and its rules, is these bugs occurring, or at least being reported, enough to make it a serious human issue? If it's not then I'd concur with business as usual plus the notifications and caveats that Petr suggested.

One coding compromise that may or may not be possible would be to disable en passant completely. That "law"'s applicability would also depend on the balance between the loss of en passant versus the inappropriate loss of pawns (perhaps in particular when done by people exploiting the bug) but I have no idea whether what the balance would be on the side of keeping or dropping en passant.

If you do decide to keep Chess then complaints about the issue in the forum could always be directed to this thread by way of a "Sorry, but it was a compromise between losing the occasional pawn or losing Chess itself".
 
 Re: Keep running Chess tourneys? Message #23491    Replies: 0
posted by Desert Wanderer (Joe Smith) on 06/01 at 16:30
Drop the Chess tourneys. The game can't be played according to the rules, the problem can't be fixed and you are already pressed for time.
 
 Re: Keep running Chess tourneys? Message #23492    Replies: 0
posted by tjrm (Jim) on 06/01 at 17:58
I have played in chess tourneys, and also have experienced glitches in the code (though unsure if any were during tourneys). IMO: offer the tourneys with warnings. Few sign up for tourneys anyway, and I would guess the few of us who have, know about glitches.

 
 Re: Keep running Chess tourneys? Message #23493    Replies: 0
posted by tracy7 (tracy7) on 06/01 at 23:39
Probably should discontinue the chess tourneys. Players can still play regular games. :)
 
 Re: Keep running Chess tourneys? Message #23496    Replies: 0
posted by stretchboy (kurt) on 06/02 at 04:29
Oh please don't kill the chess tourneys. If a person cannot take a bit of coding faux pas then they should not play. I have another bug that has not even been mentioned and I have been fully aware of it for a long time, but I still play. I like the chess players on this site. There are some good ones, I know them well (at least their style of play), and they are fun to play against.
 
 Re: Keep running Chess tourneys? Message #23497    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 06/02 at 05:22
Hi all,

I was considering the "continue but with warnings" thing as well. Frankly think that's the best option.

Will do!

Thanks everyone.
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com

Forum software by Crowder Software
Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.