(Taking off my Founding Monkey hat and just posting as a regular person)
Well i prefer xmas myself. Mostly because as someone who is a bit dyslexic the full wort christmas can cause me a little bit of trouble and I like to avoid landmines where I can (and yet I choose to contribute to this thread :).
It is worth pointing out that a couple of things (all in the spirit of learning and fun):
1) To be pedantic it isn't his birthday so much as when people choose to celebrate it. From what little infomation exists from the source material (which is a second hand account at best), we are probably off by 3-4 months. The end of December was chosen by the catholic church to coincide with the pagan festival of Saternallia.
2) The x is no more or less religious than the word christ. Not that you implied it was, I just find this stuff facinating. You can read about it here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xmas
3) Christ isn't actually Jesus's name. It is his title. It means "annointed" or more loosely "the chosen." Of course JesusMas just doesn't have the same ring. :)
Hello, I'm Catholic and I would like to correct something you posted. You said the Church chose Christmas to coincide with Saternalia.
That's not true. The Church chose December 25th as the celebration for Christ's birth--though it didn't happen on that day/night--for a great variety of reasons. They don't choose a holiday based on another religion's holiday date, On Christmas day, there's a Mass for the celebration. That's why its called Christ Mass=Christmas.
Besides that, Saternalia lasts an entire month whereas Christmas doesn't last that long. How in the world could that be a coincidence?
Wikipedia isn't a reliable encyclopedia. Anyone can come along and change the entries to suit their own biased purposes. Its best to look these things up from impartial and also official sources.
To be most correct I said that the church chose the date to coincide with Saternalia -- most specifically the great feast of Saternalia which happens at the end of the festival. The Catholic Church at various times moved the dates of various celebrations (the most famous being xMas and Easter) and masses to aid in the conversion of various groups. This is well documented.
Hit send a little too early. While it is true the Wikipedia can be edited by anyone, that does not mean that it is inaccurate. Indeed a recent letter to the journal Nature showed that for Scientific entries the error rates between the Encylopedia Britanica and Wikipedia were very similar. Regarless of that, how about another source: [url]http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_761556859/Christmas.html[url]
Specifically:
Scholars believe the frequently used shortened form of Christmas—Xmas—may have come into use in the 13th century. The X stands for the Greek letter chi, an abbreviation of Khristos (Christ), and also represents the cross on which Jesus was crucified.
and
Historians are unsure exactly when Christians first began celebrating the Nativity of Christ. However, most scholars believe that Christmas originated in the 4th century as a Christian substitute for pagan celebrations of the winter solstice. Before the introduction of Christmas, each year beginning on December 17 Romans honored Saturn, the ancient god of agriculture, in a festival called Saturnalia. This festival lasted for seven days and included the winter solstice, which usually occurred around December 25 on the ancient Julian calendar. ... Although the Gospels describe Jesus’ birth in detail, they never mention the date, so historians do not know on what date he was born. The Roman Catholic Church chose December 25 as the day for the Feast of the Nativity in order to give Christian meaning to existing pagan rituals.
BTW Saternalia lasts a week -- not a month -- from the 17th to the 25th. The common greeting during that time was "Io Saternalia!" with "io" being pronounced "Yo!" Considering the modern connotation of "yo" it makes me smile with I think of it.
It has always been Christmas for me and always will be. :)
Forum
software by
Crowder Software Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.