Pocket-Monkey(tm) Discussion Forum

[Home] | [The Catchall Cafe] | Death of Steve Irwin[Forum Rules] [Login]

Death of Steve Irwin

Thread #637 - Messages: 20   (some may be hidden) **This thread is closed** 
 Death of Steve Irwin Message #3452    Replies: 5
posted by restivo46 (Paul) on 09/04 at 07:12
Steve Irwin - The Crocodile Hunter was killed today (Monday here in Australia) stung by a Stingray in the ocean near Queensland. It just goes to show that the ocean near Australia can be lethal with not just Sharks, Blue Ringed Octapus and now Stingrays.

He was a GREAT Australian.
Paul
 
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3455    Replies: 0
posted by Mo (Mo) on 09/04 at 14:45
It was a freak accident. Stingrays are docile creatures but they will defend themselves if threatened.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/
 
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3456    Replies: 0
posted by Mo (Mo) on 09/04 at 14:46
It was a freak accident. Stingrays are docile creatures but they will defend themselves if threatened.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/
 
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3457    Replies: 1
posted by Phantom Callie (Phantom Callie) on 09/04 at 18:19
It's so sad. It almost reminds me of the Timothy Treadwell story.
Rest in peace, Croc Hunter.
   
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3461    Replies: 1
posted by Mo (Mo) on 09/05 at 12:37
What happened to Steve Irwin was a freak accident. He just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. I fully expected him to die by croc actually. To be killed by a fish....a docile fish....oh well. &#$* happens.

Timothy Treadwell is another story. It was pure stupidity & ignorance (arrogance) that killed him. No accident. The bears were doing what they do by nature....surviving.
     
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3468    Replies: 0
posted by Phantom Callie (Phantom Callie) on 09/06 at 03:34
I said it reminds me, not that they were the same. The news report has related the two stories as well; people killed by animals they love.
 
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3460    Replies: 0
posted by Pippi (SANDY) on 09/05 at 04:08
Yes Paul it was a sad day for many y'day, he was a great aussie icon, but i never thought he would die this way, from a crock yes, he even pulled the sting out of himself before he passed away, he hit in the No:1 charts on TV he will be remembered for a long time, poor little Bindie his daughter, she was following in her dads foot steps, so sad for them all..
 
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3463    Replies: 1
posted by goofball38 (goofball38) on 09/05 at 16:54
It is so incredibly sad. I was in shock when I heard it on the tv. I just hope his wife and kids will be ok. That has to be hard but at least he died doing what he loved. He was a huge icon to us all and I am sure he will be remembered for years and years to come. Such a horrible way to die though.

RIP Mr. Irwin
   
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3477    Replies: 3
posted by Silverwalker (Silverwalker) on 09/08 at 00:29
Oh, for ... yes, it's sad when someone dies, but don't act and react like it'd be someone you know just because you've seen his face on television and heard his voice. Look in your paper; someone died today that didn't know you either, like Irwin. And you take that without shock or sorrow - like you should, because people die all the time. But when you have seen a face and heard a voice, your brain clicks and makes the false connection that it's someone close to you, a condition human instincts for group survival make you mourn more.

Like when the foreign minister here was stabbed and died. Like many others. Except her face had been on TV, so people were "shocked" all over the country. For her, not for the many others. One woman, I recall, a teacher, cried on the news when stopped on her bike by a news team. I wonder if she had been riding her bike crying all the way from home, or if the tears came when she got her fifteen seconds.

So here's a lesson for today: train yourselves to accept reality when death comes to Irwin in the same matter-of-fact way that you accept the countless deaths that you're all aware of happen all the time, like NOW! - and around the clock. And if you think I sound cold, remember you're the ones mourning one stranger far more than other strangers because you've seen him on TV.
     
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3488    Replies: 1
posted by goofball38 (goofball38) on 09/08 at 17:24
Just because you don't think he was worth crying over doesn't mean the rest of us feel that way. The world has lost a great man. Let us mourn the way we want to. You have no right to tell us otherwise.
       
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3651    Replies: 3
posted by Silverwalker (Silverwalker) on 09/27 at 03:23
Wow, way to use debating tricks, goofball.

"Just because you don't think he was worth crying over" - really, where did I say that? Show me. You are twisting my words.

"You have no right to tell us otherwise." Interesting, where do I claim the "right" to give you orders? Show me. Once again, you are twisting my words.

These are two perfect examples of the strawman argument: exaggerating or distorting someone's position in a debate to make him easier to attack, when you are unable to deal with his real position. Very common - happens in 90 percent of debates, I'd estimate.


Now tell me how many of the Australians who are also strangers to you and who died today, and who were just as good people or better than Steve Irwin, that you cried over? And how many of the 6,000 Americans who died today, and the more than 9,000 Europeans? You too, Icklepi and Foreverfarm. How many?

Yeah. That's what I thought. Enjoy your TV reality, but don't tell me your hypocrisy would make you more moral. What would impress me is if you'd care about strangers when you haven't seen their faces, just as much as when you have.

Amazing that my quite concise comment would arouse such ire - or perhaps not. When you cry over people just because you've seen them on the telly, ignoring the rest, I am not surprised you wouldn't take the time to contemplate my argument without making it something personal.
         
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3742    Replies: 1
posted by goofball38 (goofball38) on 10/06 at 05:14
Silverwalker

You have no right to come on this site and start fights with people just because you are bored or old or whatever you are. I'm sorry your life is so crappy you have to come on here and criticize people for having emotions for someone who was a great person. You have a lot to learn about human emotion and compassion. Why don't you go start another fight on another thread...oh thats right you already have. You don't know me or any of these other people. All you are is someone who thinks you know everything and you definitely don't. You have no right to tell people how to feel.

"Interesting, where do I claim the "right" to give you orders?"

you might want to read what you posted again..right here

"train yourselves to accept reality when death comes to Irwin in the same matter-of-fact way that you accept the countless deaths that you're all aware of happen all the time"

I in no way have to do anything you think you have the wisdom of preaching to me or anyone else. Get a life and stop harassing people on their posts. This is a GAME site for Gods sake not a place where you can rip people down and badger them about their OPINIONS.

           
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3743    Replies: 0
posted by goofball38 (goofball38) on 10/06 at 05:17
"Wow, way to use debating tricks, goofball."

In no way am I trying to debate this or death. I'm trying to show what a cold hearted prick you are.
         
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3744    Replies: 0
posted by icklepi (Karen) on 10/06 at 08:04


I cried when Bambi's mother died, when Bruce Willis' character died in Armageddon and when a school friend was murdered - emotions are illogical just ask Mr Spock! I am sorry if you're offended that I found your view cynical. But I dont think I am hypocritical or a more moral person just because my emotions and emotional reactions are different to yours.

         
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3805    Replies: 0
posted by foreverfarm1 (theresa d) on 10/10 at 13:24
WEll if you really wanna know - I cry for people I dont know all the time - I cried for the Amish children the sicko killed in Pennsylvania - I cry for the mother whose son is arrested and I cry at sad tales - AND I cry when any animal is abused or dies because some idiot didnt feed it or bring it out of the cold AND I cried for The loss of a fellow Animal lover (did you not read my first post Silver?) -
     
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3522    Replies: 1
posted by Phantom Callie (Phantom Callie) on 09/11 at 23:28
Steve was one of my favorite people in the world. He fought for animal rights, an issue very dear to my heart. The reason he was on TV was because he actually acted so hard to save these creatures. I don't mourn him because I've seen him on TV; I mourn him because of what he did.
       
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3652    Replies: 0
posted by Silverwalker (Silverwalker) on 09/27 at 03:25
Finally, a reasonable argument!
     
 Re: Death of Steve Irwin Message #3564    Replies: 0
posted by icklepi (Karen) on 09/19 at 18:57
You're being very cynical ... those who watched Steve Irwin's programs gave their time and in a strange way that allows them to be shocked and saddened - I dont watch soaps so if a soap star died, it would still be all over the media but I wouldnt be upset unlike, and this is the important bit, if someone I liked had died as in the case of Steve Irwin. He didnt know me, prolly didnt care a toss if an english gal was sitting watching but that doesnt mean we cant like them... Whilst writing this countless people have prolly died and been born. But I didnt know anything about them. So I will quite happily accept that fact. I knew something about Mr Irwin. He loved animals, had a family and had a passion for crocs. Some people will always over-react but then again the TV stations aren't going to show people going 'who? dunno who that is?' are they?
 croc hunter Message #3490    Replies: 0
posted by foreverfarm1 (theresa d) on 09/08 at 19:48
I was extremely sad to hear the croc hunter died, because he did some interesting things...not because he was on tv...He was an animal spokesperson and showed people alot about animals that they would normally be afraid of. Because animals mean alot to me and I want more people to like them so that people will care about them too, I care more about Steve dying than I do about joe smoe from the death notices.

I know his family will be fine - I mean crikey, they have to have a ton of money which releaves a huge burden when the father/husband dies.

besides - I can cry if I want to and dont really care if anyone likes it or not!
 HEY, I'VE GOT IT...... Message #4135    Replies: 0
posted by SUPER T (TONY) on 11/03 at 04:23
How about I start a self-help group for u knuckleheads interested in debating not whether Steve irwin was a great guy but, of the verbage u used to describe it. I'm led to believe that if any of the chuckleheads from Jackass the movie, died, there would be mass similtaneous suicide in this forum.

LIGHTEN UP, GROUP HUGS EVERYONE.......SHEESH

Forum software by Crowder Software
Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.