Pocket-Monkey(tm) Discussion Forum

[Home] | [The Catchall Cafe] | The Christmas Tree[Forum Rules] [Login]

The Christmas Tree

Thread #1130 - Messages: 37   (some may be hidden) **This thread is closed** 
 The Christmas Tree Message #9590    Replies: 4
posted by DJ (Dave) on 12/04 at 15:03
To the best of my knowledge the Christmas tree was introduced into England by Queen Victoria and the Prince Consort in the 19th century. When did your part of the world start dressing trees and do you have any idea of which country originated the idea?
 
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9591    Replies: 1
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/04 at 16:25
I am sure that a better historian than myself could give you a precise answer, but in the pre-US colonies it would have been somewhere between 1680 to 1720 when there would have been enough German and Dutch settlers in the US to popularize the tradition.
   
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9597    Replies: 1
posted by DJ (Dave) on 12/06 at 01:55
The German connection certainly makes sense to Me, Victoria's Consort, Price Albert was a German.
     
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9599    Replies: 0
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/06 at 02:37
Indeed and that is why, too this day, the royal family opens their presents on xmas eve. Why I know this, and why it sticks in my head is more of a mystery :)
 
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9618    Replies: 2
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/08 at 02:50
Way back around 600 BC, before the Babylonians destroyed Judah, the prophet Jeremiah warned the kings, priests and people about the coming of God's judgement and their destruction. These people were worshipping idols (heathens) instead of God.

Look at what Jeremiah said in the bible;

Hear ye the word which the LORD speaketh unto you, O house of Israel: Thus saith the LORD, Learn not the way of the heathen, and be not dismayed at the signs of heaven; for the heathen are dismayed at them. For the customs of the people are vain: for one cutteth a tree out of the forest, the work of the hands of the workman, with the axe. They deck it with silver and with gold; they fasten it with nails and with hammers, that it move not.
(Jeremiah 10:1-4)
   
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9619    Replies: 2
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/08 at 04:55
Interesting. And a bit hard to verify (not the quote, that is easy :), but the archeology), also kinda misses the core question. It was when was the xmas tree first introduced to your country.

I was going to post a long boring bit here about how so much of the xmas tradition comes from pagan/pre-Christian traditions, etc, etc, etc; and then I thought no. Not this year. It happens every year -- that conversation. Either here or on many many other sites. And so this year in the great Christmas, Hanukkah, Solstice, New Year, Saturnalia, Kwanzaa, "Hey it's cold, let's all get together, eat, and be nice to one another," what have you tradition let us all just take that whole bit as read, and talk about trees. :)
     
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9621    Replies: 1
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/08 at 06:02
"...do you have any idea of which country originated the idea?"

Israel.
       
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9622    Replies: 1
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/08 at 06:39
Can you site a historical reference (other than the one you just did), or an archeological one?
         
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9626    Replies: 1
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/08 at 12:48
Of course not, Jerusalem was utterly destroyed in 586 BC. The reference to the decorated tree can only be found in scripture some twenty years earlier.
           
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9628    Replies: 1
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/08 at 16:04
All I was driving at is that the Old Testament is a really tricky document to site for historical discussions, for the whole verification question. Unless we can externally verify, we are basically taking the word of someone about something that happened a long time ago. The other thing is we don't know if it was the first.

Now that being said, I do want to apologize for not saying this bit before (when I meant to). That is a really interesting quote. It does show just how old this kind of thing could be (ie the better part of 3 thousand years. A big part of why I asked for a second source is because I want to learn more about it. Why this idea seems to be build into us so deeply


             
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9629    Replies: 1
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/08 at 16:45
Like TJ said, you'd be bordering on the paganism topic, and do we really want to go there here? I know where to find lots of info if thats what you're wanting.

The bottom line is, Jesus wasn't born on December 25, nor was He born in the winter. Xmas is a catholic spinoff from paganism in the OT.
               
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9630    Replies: 1
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/08 at 16:54
1) I believe you meant DJ not TJ
2) The post I believe you are referring to is mine, not DJ's (or TJ's)
                 
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9631    Replies: 1
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/08 at 16:57
Yes, it was yours, sorry.
                   
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9635    Replies: 1
posted by ayegotcha (AyeGotcha) on 12/08 at 19:32
Let's just enjoy the tree, for wherever it came from, we know what it symbolizes in our hearts!
                     
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9637    Replies: 1
posted by DJ (Dave) on 12/08 at 20:25
Well I have done a little surfing but can find nothing earlier than mid 16th century, mid European, Possibly Slovak which would make sense as they have an abundance of evergreen trees.
How it became an idea to bring them indoors and decorate them still evades me though.
                       
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9638    Replies: 2
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/08 at 21:32
Let me give you a logical but unprovable. Consider walking through a cluster of trees in the snow -- perhaps on a moonlight night -- you come to the center and there is one tree there. It is all covered in frost, the light is being bounced up from the ground. It is going to have this shimmering beautiful look, almost magical. If you live in a region like that (like most of Europe at the time), can you imagine a more appropriate symbol of the time?

Now like I say, it is logical and unprovable. There are stories (most likely apocryphal) that the pre-christian Germanic tribes used nature and tree worship, which is why when missionaries from Rome went out they used the triangular tree shape to explain the trinity. Again, most likely apocryphal.
                         
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9639    Replies: 0
posted by DJ (Dave) on 12/09 at 06:37
Sounds a fair theory to me.
                         
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9640    Replies: 1
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/09 at 06:50
Sounds a fairy theory to me.
                           
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9641    Replies: 0
posted by DJ (Dave) on 12/09 at 09:27
Oh very good, yes I got a good smile from it. LOL
     
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9679    Replies: 1
posted by Silverwalker (Silverwalker) on 12/15 at 00:03
Jock, "Kwanzaa"? "Hanukkah," one of the most insignificant times in the Judaist calendar until a Zionist got pissed that his fellow Jews in the U.S. celebrated Christmas and wanted to dilute the day, and some Jews in the media decided to help? "Saturnalia"? "Solstice"? Give me a break. You politically correct Americans need to get your heads screwed on. You only mention those things because Christmas comes from Europe, and therefore must not be allowed to shine alone.
       
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9682    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 12/15 at 10:45
Let's keep this polite, guys. Remember that Pocket-Monkey is not the place for contentious political or religious discussion.
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com

   
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9661    Replies: 1
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/12 at 07:59
From http://www.graceandtruth.net/

The "Christmas Tree" finds its beginning at Babylon as the Ashteroth (the female moon deity represented as a tree). Upon the expulsion of the sun and moon (Baal and the Groves) worship from Babylon, the "Seat of Satan" relocated at Pergamos (Rev. 2:13). The king of Pergamos (Attalus III) died and left his Chaldean system of magic and superstition to Rome by will and testament. Upon organizing the Romanist Church, Constantine not only implemented the Chaldean system of Sun and Moon worship into his church, he adapted their annual 7 day festival of drunken revelry and riotous immorality. The festival, called the Saturnalia, was given the name Christmass within the church. The Astarte (grove - Ashteroth - Venus) or "Christmas Tree" was an integral part of this festival. From Two Babylons by Alexander Hislop:

The Christmas tree now so common among-us, was equally common in Pagan Rome and Pagan Egypt. In Egypt, that tree was the Palm Tree; in Rome it was the "fir".

The mother of Adonis, the sun god and great mediatorial divinity, was mystically said to have been changed into a tree, and when in that state to have brought forth a divine son. If the mother was the tree, the son must have been recognized as "Man the Branch" (a corruption of Zechariah's prophecy concerning Christ, the branch of God - Zech. 6:12). This accounts for the putting of the yule-log into the fire Christmas Eve and the appearing of the Christmas tree the next morning. As Zero-Ashta, "the seed of woman," which name also signified "born of the fire" (the fire god), he has to enter the fire on "Mother night" (December 24th in the ancient world), that he may be born the next day (December 25th) out of it, as the "Branch of God", or the Tree that brings all divine gifts to men. Thus, we see on Christmas morning the gifts under and around the tree as his gifts to his worshipers. December 25th was known far and wide throughout the pagan world as the exact birthday of Adonis the tree god (Allah) of Babylon. This Venus-Tree worship, along with her consort Baal (the sun), corrupted Israel, invoking the wrath of God for their idolatry. This goddess of the groves was imported from Babylon (Iraq) into Israel upon the marriage of Ahab, King of Northern Israel, to Jezebel, the daughter of Ethbaal, a priest of the Ashtoreth of Babylon (I Kings 16:31). God's judgement for such wickedness has been to purge Israel for 2600 years with sword, famine, and pestilence (Jer. 29:17-19). Jesus was born of a virgin. He was God in the flesh. He died and shed his blood as an atonement for sin that all who believe in him will have eternal life. However, Christmas (the Saturnalia) and The Christmas Tree (Venus - the groves) have nothing to do with his birth. We have corrupted ourselves.
     
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9666    Replies: 1
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/13 at 06:29
I am wondering if you might be better off citing secular sources. Using the bible as a historical work is problematic. For a variety of reasons, not the least of which is translation issues. If you look at the quote from Jeremiah you gave above in other translations of the work it refers to the carved idol made out of a tree, not the tree itself.
       
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9667    Replies: 1
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/13 at 15:43
From the above Jeremiah verse;

"They deck it with silver and with gold..."

The word 'it' refers to tree I believe.
         
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9668    Replies: 1
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/13 at 15:59
I would invite you to look at http://bible.cc/jeremiah/10-3.htm and compare. Look at the non King James inspired works. They clearly talk about a tree being cut then carved. If you look at the other verses it seems clear that it is talking about carved status of idols. Not trees.

More to the point, and this is the last I am going to say on the matter: No matter what else the bible might be it is not a reliable document for archeology or history. If you want to us it, fine. You had also better be prepared to have other texts to back it up.
           
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9669    Replies: 1
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/14 at 03:45
http://bible.cc/jeremiah/10-4.htm

How many non KJV's are there? I'll use the KJV always.
             
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9670    Replies: 1
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/14 at 03:52
clearly this thread has spiraled out of control, and has just become a religious debate between two people. The forums are not the place for that on a game site. If you want to discuss this further feel free to private message me (or not). I for one am going to step out of this thread.
               
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9673    Replies: 1
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/14 at 07:17
"The forums are not the place for that on a game site."

Paste the site link where it says that.
                 
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9674    Replies: 0
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/14 at 07:50
I was speaking of my personal opinion. If you wish to keep posting about this here, that is up to you.
 
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9678    Replies: 1
posted by Silverwalker (Silverwalker) on 12/14 at 23:57
I note that "some dream"'s story from that URL doesn't cite anything particular about the Christmas Tree. So, nice try.

NOW, HERE IS HOW IT GOT STARTED: The Christmas tree got started in Germany in the 15th century. This is what we learn in school in Sweden, and several historical sources say the same thing. Just google it, for God's sake.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christmas_tree

That link says 16th century Germany, but I have always heard 15th century Germany, and the Swedish version of wikipedia says 15th century Germany.


Yes, trees have been used in religious ceremonies before. But to actually bring a tree into the home, comes from Germany in the 15th century.

Fun fact: red balls in the tree and other things that we put in it, are a reminder of the sacrifice that used to be hung in trees, like goats, sheep, and the occasional human if there was a war going and you needed the gods to be extra nice.
   
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9680    Replies: 0
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/15 at 04:30
"I note that "some dream"'s story from that URL doesn't cite anything particular about the Christmas Tree."

It wasn't my story. The first line in the pasted text from the URL says 'Christmas Tree'. So, nice try.

Wikipedia is communally constructed thus probably the least factually reliable. I mean, if you searched that site for the word 'fairies', it'd probably find some 'facts' to throw back at you.

Where did your 'Fun fact' come from? It refers to multiple gods, that of course being how the bible refers to paganism.

Just a biblical fact.
 
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9683    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 12/15 at 10:46
I think this thread has reached the end of its natural life, guys. If you want to discuss this further, please take it private.

Thank you,
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com

   
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9684    Replies: 1
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/15 at 12:24
I've already been receiving private messages from one of the posters here, and that can be annoying at times.

I only use the Discussion Forum when there's a drought with my game play, so its not a good idea to promote private messaging, since it can interfere with game play when/if busy.

I'd suggest you create a 'Politics' header or similar, as can be found at sites like www.dailygammon.com. Kids tend to stay away from such places.

Why don't you delete this topic if that's what you want?
     
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9687    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 12/15 at 16:15
Hi,

If you don't want private messages from people, tell them that. If they keep at it, use the ignore list. That's what it's for.

Private messages don't interfere with game play. It's not like they pop up in front of you without your asking. But if they're bothering you, you can get people to stop sending them.

We don't have a politics forum because we're not a politics discussion site. We're a friendly little board game site. There are about a million politics discussion sites out there for people to enjoy. :-) It's not something we're interested in doing here.

We don't delete topics or posts within topics except in extremely rare cases of truly egregious content being posted.

Enjoy your games,
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com

       
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9698    Replies: 2
posted by DJ (Dave) on 12/16 at 17:43
I'm sorry about this T.J. My original post was purely of personal interest, I never intended to cause distention amongst the game playing population. Sorry to all I have caused bad feeling amongst. All of your comments have been read and I thank you for the information.

May your personal God give you all you wish this Christmas, one and all.
         
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9699    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 12/16 at 20:25
Not your fault, DJ! And it's just that this probably should end now, not that there's some big problem...

-- T.J. :-)
         
 Re: The Christmas Tree Message #9700    Replies: 0
posted by some dream (some dream) on 12/17 at 06:22
Thanks for the questions, I hope you found the answers you were looking for. I don't know why there so many irrelevant answers, but still, its only a discussion forum.

Forum software by Crowder Software
Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.