Just to inform my opponants, if you double a backgammon game that you know you will win I find it totaly un-gentelmanly, bad mannerd, and totaly bad cricket. I will refuse the double and not play you again. Doubling adds to the fun when both stand a chance of winning.
Sorry you feel that way Dave. Sometimes I do it just to speed up the game, I will usually wait till they have at least one off. To play out a game you know you can't win is boring. I would rather move on to the next and try to forget how bad I got beat.
But if you find the game boring why play in the first place? Win or loose is no great deal, it's the fun of playing that matters. By shutting a game prematurely you are saying to your opponant that you are bored with their company.
The doubling cubes there so can be used.. Gives the oppponent, chance to make up there mind whether to take the risk. I find it just as much fun deciding whether to take the risk. :-)
Sorry Dot, I can't agree with that, the fun must be the game, playing it, not ending it early just because you know you are going to win. That is a cowards way. The British are brought up to fight to the last man and the bitter end whatever the outcome.
DJ, i somewhat agree with you, i find it bad to hurt a man just cause he is down. My solution to that is to not play any matches with the cube.
Re: Games you know you are going to win
Message #14001 Replies: 1
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 12/19 at 19:06
I think doubling the game to move the game on when there is no hope of winning is a personal prefrence something which i do on occasion. What I find bad sportsmanship is when someone offers you a double when they are obviously going to win but have very few moves to make to finsih that round. That does get me goat!
There is no insult. It's a perfectly legit way of allowing somebody to bail out of a game they can't win and letting them restart on a level playing field.
From the other side of the coin I don't see much joy in continuing a game I'm not going to win. It's almost as if the other player is gloating by not offering the double and prolonging ignominy.
It certainly doesn't say "I'm bored with you" either because I'm invariably happy to play again.
Good suggestion Play Time.
Re: Games you know you are going to win
Message #14005 Replies: 2
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 12/19 at 22:23
Im not saying I dont offer the double *as some say:- thats what it is there for* and yes those that dont like doubling at all then maybe the *No Cube* games would be more appropriate. I am saying however surely there is bad play *I.E as i stated, offering a double to someone when there is only a couple of moves left in the game* why not just play those two or three moves out. I play both as i enjoy both. But those kind of doubles I dont like.
LOL - yep, that's the Tracey I know of old, wanting to see somebody squirming in the agony of defeat until the very last moment!!!
(Did you ever find the mistletoe?)
Re: Games you know you are going to win
Message #14008 Replies: 1
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 12/19 at 23:00
Well there is that to it...LOL..
(still looking LOL)
Actually I was looking at it the other way round. When im offered a double, when I am losing and the game has only a few moves left to go. Id rather play it out and lose gracefully than have a double thrown at me I am obviously going to decline. I look at that as bad Etiquette. Thats my opinion and I am sticking to it...lol...
I love the doubles when you have to sit and ponder...do I?? Or Dont I??? The ones that really get you thinking.Not the ones to just *MOVE* a game on! Isnt that what we are here for?? TO play, interact and have fun??? :O)
That's the perenial question - why is each of us here? Since the answer to that seems to influence whether we like these apparently dodgy doubles, Jim (below) seems to have exactly the right idea. Who can tell. without discussion, whether your opponent will relish or abhor this action.
I will, therefore, continue to offer doubles that enable somebody a quick way out and moves on the game, and hope they make the same offer to me.
Re: Games you know you are going to win
Message #14015 Replies: 1
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 12/20 at 11:25
As I said before it all comes down to personal prefrence and what we want from the game? Do we come here to play and enjoy socialising or do we come here to win and up our "ELO" rating!? I know what I prefer!!
I believe we often err in deciphering another person's motives. Speaking for myself, I attempt to use the doubling cube in a manner that is objectively correct -- judged by logic and/or strategy. I judge my opponents doubles as meaning that this is their assessment as well. No offense intentionally taken or given.
Re: Games you know you are going to win
Message #14009 Replies: 1
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 12/19 at 23:01
Please dont get me wrong, doubling a game can and does add excitement but not when it is used just to end a game. Please have the good manners to make those last few moves.
Re: Games you know you are going to win
Message #14014 Replies: 0
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 12/20 at 11:23
Good manners? Phil states correctly that one often does not know the preferences of an opponent. Speaking only for myself again, I find myself sometimes wondering why an opponent has not doubled to enable our moving on to the next game. I do not resign in such cases as the antidote partly because that would, to me, seem bad manners and partly because I fear a bad click would lose the match as well as the game. All this said, I have indeed played "just a couple" moves instead of doubling from a sense that the double served little purpose in the case, and the expectation that my opponent would perceive it the same way. Quite frankly, until this forum topic, I had never imagined my doubling might be interpreted as bad manners, -- at least among experienced backgammon players, -- so long as defensible by strategy or logic. Certainly, I don't recall ever perceiving an opponent's double as bad manners in nearly 50 years of playing.
posted by pint of beer (john shields) on 12/20 at 19:28
all i will say on this subject of doubling. i suggested to T.J. a long time ago to have none doubling backgammon (that had been around for centuries). he agreed and you can play none doubling backgammon on here it`s the only site i know that has this feature. i prefer the none doubling cube backgammon games.
I don't do doubling. I feel that people like to double just to push their ratings up.Me? I don't do ratings cause I like to have fun without pressure of worring about how I rate.
You know, some people can be really evil. They challenge you to play and then have the outrageous temerity to try to win. May they rot eternally in the septic tank of insidious ambition!
Oh my Phil, that was a bit strong, a good smile though which I think what chat boards should be all about. I try to get people to talk to each other all the time. :o)
Lol - it was meant to be laden thickly with irony but I'm not being at all ironic when I say thanks for stimulating a good debate.
>80)
Re: Games you know you are going to win
Message #14034 Replies: 1
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 12/21 at 11:04
Rules on etiquette may not be in black and white but they are necessary for common courtesy. They also make sure that the playing atmosphere remains congenial. :o)
So apart from avoiding the issue (there are countless errors of grammar, spelling and meaning just on this page) what was your pount?
>80)
Re: Games you know you are going to win
Message #14040 Replies: 2
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 12/21 at 15:04
My “point” is that everyone perceives the use of the doubling cube in different ways. That’ the “unwritten” rules of good sportsmanship may be perceived differently depending on what each person wants to get out of their game playing and interaction with players/friends on the site. For instance I had an invite from a player for a BG match 21 with use of doubling cube. At the beginning of each game he would double. I didn’t see the point (or skill) in that and I preferred not to play him again. That was my personal preference. I also prefer not to play games where people offer a double a few moves from the end to “move the game on”. Again this is my personal preference. I enjoy both the use of the doubling cube and the games without so play both. I have also started this self same discussion over on the backgammon forum sometime ago when someone called me “rude” for offering what I felt was a very good use of the cube and it started a good discussion as did this. I think I have already put my own personal point across already in this discussion in previous posts in this thread and don’t need to add anymore.
Myopic as always, I was unaware of so frequent use of the doubling cube to send opponents messages. But focusing on the strategy I would point out that: 1) in the case of an opponent routinely doubling at the beginning of each game, your routinely accepting would give you a strategic advantage -- the probabilities in the case described do not favor the opponent and you get control of the cube. 2) in the case of a game just a few moves from the end but not mathematically impossible (just improbable) for the opponent to win, I have frequently observed that some opponents have not trained themselves to assess the probabilities with reasonable accuracy, or perhaps are unwilling to do so, or that they knowingly accept doubles that are objectively bad risks. Offering a double in this case is good strategy and focuses on the backgammon skill.
Possibly the comments in this forum were meant only to refer to cases of 100% probability. In that case, my personal preference -- and from "chat" with opponents, a preference that is shared fairly widely -- is to offer the double as a way to move on to the next game (a consequence desired by both of us). I do greatly second Tracy's thought that one should choose opponents -- when one has a choice based on the compatibility of your preferences.
My conclusion then, as nobody has convinced me it is bad sportsmanship to progress the game by offering a double from an insurmountable position, is that I will continue to do so and hope that my opponent has the grace to do the same.
This does not make me overly ambitious, it does not mean I'm obsessed with ELO scores, it does not mean that I am unfriendly in any way but it might mean that if my opponent is offended by it, we are both playing with the wrong person.
Fexxy out.
Re: Games you know you are going to win
Message #14052 Replies: 1
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 12/22 at 13:39
Hey, come on you pair, this is a time of love to all.
May I take this oppertunity to wish all that play here the best wishes of the seson, to thank the big bosses (they know who they are) for proving me with lots of new friends.
if you double a backgammon game that you know you will win I find it totaly un-gentelmanly, bad mannerd, and totaly bad cricket
Just for what it's worth, I'm pretty sure that in backgammon clubs and any decent-level play, it's not only not bad manners, but normal practice. So it may be worth assuming your opponent is used to playing in those sorts of contexts and is doing what's normal, rather than taking offense.
In general, in fact, I counsel players that if their opponent's actions can be construed in more than one way, assume the best rather than the worst.
For my part, the only impolite double I can think of would be if the game will already decide the entire match -- e.g., you're playing to 5, you both already have 3, and the cube is at 2. At that point, the player holding the cube could double, but there's no reason to -- the game already decides the match, because if either player wins, they get 2 points and win the match. I'm pretty sure our Backgammon game actually prevents doubling in that situation, since it's pointless.
But again, not trying to convince you that it's not bad manners, just trying to point out that for a lot of decent players, it not only isn't bad manners, but is the normal thing to do. So even if you disagree and you wouldn't do it, it's worth assuming the best of their intentions.
As always, enjoy your games!
-- T.J. :-)
Forum
software by
Crowder Software Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.