You tourney players out there will be glad to know that before too long, we'll be addressing the "moot game" problem. I have a question for you all about that, but first let's establish what I mean by a "moot game" and explain briefly why we care about them:
What is a "moot game"?
It's a game that is still in progress but can't change the outcome of the tournament section it's in.
Example 1: Let's say Ahmed has already finished all his games and has 10 points, the current high score in his section. Now, suppose Andy and Maria are still playing their game in that same section, but Andy has 4 points and Maria has 6. Their game is moot, it cannot change the result in that section: If Andy wins, he ends up with 6 points -- not enough to win or tie Ahmed. If Maria wins, she ends up with 8 points -- still not enough. Either way, Ahmed will win the section.
Example 2: Moot games can involve the person winning the section, too: Let's say Janet has 10 points and one game still in progress against Nitin, who has 6 points. Let's say everyone else is done, but no one has as many points as Janet does. Janet and Nitin's game is moot, because Janet will win the section regardless of whether she wins the game. She'll win the section with 10 points (if she loses to Nitin) or 12 (if she wins), but it doesn't change the outcome.
Why do we care about moot games?
Because they hold up tournaments. By preventing the site from declaring a winner for that section, they prevent it declaring a winner for the round (if the other sections are complete), which prevents the next round from starting. If we disregard the moot games, we can keep the tournaments moving along better.
Are there really that many of them?
About 430 right now, including 39 that are preventing 30 tournaments from moving on to the next round. We currently have about 327 tournaments running, so that's nearly 10% of tournaments that are waiting unnecessarily.
Okay, so, the question: I'm looking for a better term than "moot game". :-) For one thing, "moot" is a (somewhat) high-falutin' word. For another, it's only accurate in relation to the tourney; the game isn't moot to the players playing it (or to their stats). And when discussing this early on (a while back, now), a couple of people thought it was a bit insulting.
So, anyone have any suggestions? (Please don't take it wrong if we don't go with your suggestion, or indeed if we don't go with any of them, but your input would be valuable...)
I actually quite like “moot” game but then if you asked anybody to describe me in 6 words, high-falutin’ is likely to appear somewhere. Unfortunately, one missing word would be “imaginative” but I’ll throw some ideas in as it might stimulate somebody else’s little grey cells.
What about:
Honour (ok – honor if you must) since the game is being played out for the honour of those remaining rather the title. In the same way it could be called a “bragging” game or a “fun” game to cater for all of those people who ‘only play for fun.’ That doesn’t really cater for scenario 2
“Tributary” game
“Side” game
“ox-bow” game (Which is the first time I have ever had any use for my ‘o’ level geography)
My favourite would be:
Pocket game which describes the fact that it is now out of the main stream of the tournament and also, haven’t I seen the word used around here before?
There's definitely something in the "nondeciding" concept (maybe even just use that word!), and "side" is pleasantly non-negative.
I would prefer to use a standard term if there is one; and there has to be one.
What does the NFL call this? Because something exactly analogous happens toward the end of the regular season: Two teams can play a game that won't change who goes to the playoffs, but does still count toward those teams' stats. So what do they call those games? I did a search, and certainly some sportswriters use "moot" in this context, but there are far too few results for it to be the common term. And this is the NFL, they have a term (and a statistician) for everything.
I've been doing some reading up, and it would appear that the verb "relegate" is sometimes used in this context, particularly in European style leagues, but it relates more to the team (in our case, player) than to the game. "Relegated games" -- not that excited by it. On top of the fact it usually relates to teams rather than games, it's at least as high-falutin' a word as "moot". If it were 100% applicable and the standard term, I'd use it anyway, but...
I wondered about "neutral": "This game has become neutral, it can't change the outcome." Enh. "Impotent" is out for obvious reasons (and as with "moot", only applies to the tourney; the game still has power related to the players' stats).
Right now, my favorite is "nondeciding". I'd like to find another way to say it, because it feels clunky, but it's pretty clear.
Keep the ideas coming, folks, and thanks.
-- T.J. :-)
Re: Wanted: A Better Term for "Moot Game"
Message #14692 Replies: 0
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 05/31 at 14:48
Exhausted (Exhaust out) Static (happy johns one) Liberate Play out Barren Effete
Okay, you got me, I had to go look up "nimiety"! :-) Probably a bit too much of a $5 word for the purpose, but thanks for the vocab! (It's a noun, so the game would just be "a nimiety".)
the name is cool but ppl shouldnt have to wait to finish the game out n ppl shouldnt have to wait till other ppl to play.some ppl wait to long to move on tourney games
That's the whole point. :-) I'm just about ready to put new code live that will disregard this non-deciding games and allow the tourney to continue even though they're not completed. So that means an entry in the help explaining to people why the game is non-deciding, notifications to people that a game has been marked non-deciding, etc., etc. Hence the search for a good term!
a. Going, tending, or moving toward a position in front. b. Sports Advancing toward an opponent's goal. c. Moving in a prescribed direction or order for normal use
On the theme of games which are "left behind", there's http://www.onelook.com/?w=*%3Astraggle which gives tail game or sidetracked game, to denote the idea that it's no longer part of the main tournament. That idea reminds me of cycle races where you have the leaders and the chasing pack, so a chaser game would be one which needs to catch up with the tourney (although that doesn't apply to the players themselves and might be confusing).
Q. What's a "sidetracked game"? When a game in a tournament section cannot affect the outcome of that section then it is sidetracked to allow the tournament to move on to the next round or even finish. Sidetracking a game doesn't actually change anything; the players continue to play out the sidetracked game and, meanwhile, the tournament moves on.
Sidetracked games still count toward the player stats, so if the site notifies you that a game has been sidetracked, don't resign or start ignoring it. All it means is that, from the tournament point of view, the game no longer has an effect.
I think that's my favourite but orphaned fits well in there, too.
GoldToken uses the same system for advancing tournament sections at the earliest opportunity but they don't notify the players explicitly, they just show the players' status (eliminated or winner on the tournment page). I think that's a good way to do it. For some people it can become bothersome to be told every time that it happens. Some will already understand and expect it; others will think, despite the FAQ blurb, that they have to do something, so you'd have to remind them that they shouldn't do anything. I think that this is a case of Ignorance is bliss. At GoldToken people can check the section status if they want to know about their games but I believe that many people are happy to play out their section without necessarily knowing that they are playing a redundant game. (Ahah, at the last second, I just found a new ordinary word for the concept! lol)
Thanks! And thanks for the links, I know I'll get good use out of the OneLook thing.
"Nug" game is great fun, which is a big point in its favor. Put it in the top three, anyway. The flip side is that it sounds a bit rude. :-)
Whatever we use is going to need to be defined anyway, so I don't think that's a mark against "nug". The nice thing about "nug" is that people are going to know they don't know what it means, and hopefully that means they'll go look at our definition.
I really like "orphaned" game -- way better than "silent".
@robin:
Thanks! I did consider "neutral" early on, but I thought it didn't quite capture things.
@all:
For me, at this point, the top three are:
Orphaned game
Moot game (yes, really)
Nug (nugatory) game
...and I'll have to run through the thread again to see if there should be a fourth or fifth on that list.
I think I feel a poll coming on... I wrote this nifty polling stuff for the site a couple of years back and I've only used it twice, I think. Just for fun, time to trot it out for a third time.
Thank you, everybody, for all the great ideas!!! I think we have enough to be going on with at this point. -- T.J. Crowder First Primate Pocket-Monkey.com
Re: Wanted: A Better Term for "Moot Game"
Message #14925 Replies: 0
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 06/27 at 11:29
Is this automatically done now? Or is it something you still have to intervine with ? Thanx
You said that moot was a bit high-falutin' but maybe an obsure high-falution' word might be useful. ;-)
From http://phrontistery.info/n.html nugacious ..... unimportant; trifling; trivial nugatory ....... inconsequential; inoperative; futile; trifling nullity ............. the state of being null or void
From the first two you could call the moot games "nug" games. That's not a word itself, of course, but it's short and quite cute and, although I say so myself, something that a monkey might like. lol ;o)
You'd have to explain what a "nug game" was, just as you have to explain what a "moot game" is but I'd bet that the word would be well adopted.
Another great source of words is the OneLook related-to dictionary function.
Another candidate related to unimportant is "inessential", which means what it sounds like. Related to that is "adjunct", which means an added part which is inessential and that's what these games become when they mootify.
Related to pointless is "otiose", which means producing no result or effect, but that's probably the highest-falutin'est word given so far. But ya might like it? ;-)
Summarising:
nug games because they are nugacious and nugatory (unimportant; trifling; trivial; inconsequential; inoperative; futile)
adjuncts because they have become inessential to the outcome.
otiose games because they produce no result or effect.
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 06/09 at 15:22
Neutral element (mathematics), a special type of element of a set with respect to a binary operation on that set, such if applied to, or operated with any element of the set, causes no change to this last element.
What about the bog standard "Neutral Game" I.e as above causing no channge?
LOL....good choice...that's how I feel sometimes when have no chance in tourney, but still have games left. Came across this thread too late to offer a suggestion, but if had sooner, would have liked 'non-key', as kind of rhymes with monkey...:)
Re: Wanted: A Better Term for "Moot Game"
Message #14957 Replies: 1
posted by robin (Happy Johns other half x) on 07/01 at 18:25
Is this automatic now? Or is it something you still have to do manually? thanx
It'll be automatic when the new code goes live, which will probably be Sunday. All of the tournies with orphaned games won't suddenly start new rounds on Sunday, though, that would probably be unpopular. They'll dribble through in the coming weeks. But from Sunday (if the code goes live then), new tournies will immediately detect orphaned games. -- T.J. Crowder First Primate Pocket-Monkey.com
Forum
software by
Crowder Software Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.