It doesn't happen often, but sometimes a tournament is a tie. So far that's happened three times here on Pocket-Monkey (links below if you're interested). The two surviving players are just so evenly matched that the tourney keeps going from one round to the next with the same two players, each of them having won one game. (As you can imagine, this can only happen in "play each side" tournies.) This is not automatic; the players have to write in saying "Can we just call it a tie?" and then we have to do it manually here behind the scenes (which is tedious).
It happens to be a good time for me to update the tournament code because of some other stuff I'm doing, and it's pretty easy to do, so I thought I'd put in the necessary code for the site to declare ties automatically rather than our having to do it manually. These are the rules I have in mind: The site will automatically declare a tournament a tie if:
It's a "play each side" style of tournament.
There have been at least four rounds in total.
There are only two players left.
There have been three rounds where those two were the only players.
(And yes, for you pedants out there, #1 is implied by #4.) So for instance, in the case of tournament #49 below, rather than Mark and sungolfer playing 27 (!) rounds on their own, the site would have automatically called the tourney a tie after round 5.
Does that seem reasonable to everyone?
A note about luck: I was thinking at one point that we would never declare a tie in games where there's an element of luck involved, such as Backgammon or (arguably) RadarWar. But exempting certain game types is more complicated, and if the same two players have split things evenly for three rounds running, it seems like that's good enough, even the luck is fairly balanced. :-)
Yeah, I can see where you're going with that. I think I'd rather make it a hard and fast rule rather than putting players in the position of making the call for themselves. I figure if it's been a draw (one game each way) three times in a row, we should probably call it a tie. :-) -- T.J. Crowder First Primate Pocket-Monkey.com
Another option would be to have a final round which has three matches instead of two. However, I imagine that it would need quite a bit more programming than counting tied rounds. ;-)
Forum
software by
Crowder Software Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.