Pocket-Monkey(tm) Discussion Forum

[Home] | [The Catchall Cafe] | rematch[Forum Rules] [Login]

rematch

Thread #1734 - Messages: 9   (some may be hidden) **This thread is closed** 
 rematch Message #17305    Replies: 2
posted by Eaglesun (bill) on 10/22 at 14:18
Ok people was wondering what the take is on rematches. Now i will offer a rematch if i win as i have made the last move it seems like the right thing to do. But I have seen that others who win espcially those with higher ratings wont offer a rematch> So let me know what is the common practice.
 
 Re: rematch Message #17308    Replies: 0
posted by playBunny (pB) on 10/22 at 14:53
Ok people was wondering what the take is on rematches. Now i will offer a rematch if i win as i have made the last move it seems like the right thing to do.
My take on it is that there's no rule or etiquette to be followed. I'd say that the guiding priciples are "each to his own", "play it by ear" and "ask your opponent" (whether they have a rematch principle).

As this is a matter of personal convention, both sides may not be on the same page regarding the matter. If a player has a winner-makes-the-invitation rule but their opponent doesn't know it then it's open to misinterpretation. Only inviting when they win and remaining silent when they lose can appear to be saying "I beat you, I'll have more of that" when they win and "I don't want to play you anymore" when they lose, which smacks of poor sportsmanship.
But I have seen that others who win espcially those with higher ratings wont offer a rematch
They may not want to appear like bad losers, as suggested above, but there are a myriad other reasons.
 
 Re: rematch Message #17310    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 10/22 at 15:43
Hi,

I'm with playBunny on this: I think it's totally up to the players involved.

An enhancement that's been on the list FOREVER is to have the option of the site sending you a note when the game ends. If you play a lot of games, and the game ended on the other player's turn, you might actually miss that the game ended!

(Two options, actually: "Tell me when a game ends" and "Don't tell me if I'm the player who made the last move" -- I figure most people mostly notice the game ended when they're the one making the last move.)

I think I'll take a break from the non-Java games stuff and spend a couple of hours doing those options, should be that quick and people have asked for it a lot.

Enjoy your games,
--
T.J. Crowder
First Primate
Pocket-Monkey.com
   
 Re: rematch Message #17317    Replies: 2
posted by Eaglesun (bill) on 10/22 at 22:39
see really all i was saying if you win the game at least offer a rematch
     
 Re: rematch Message #17350    Replies: 1
posted by Redbee (Lori) on 10/27 at 13:57
I believe it should totally be up to each individual players and games...

I play alot of games here and at different sites and mostly I do not like to always play the same player again...especially if they are rude, very slow playing or simply wont even extend a simple GL, GG, etc etc. So if i win against a person like that, then no, I wont extend a rematch and will usually decline one as well.

There really shouldnt be a "standard" way with this, to each his own as it has been said.
       
 Re: rematch Message #17351    Replies: 1
posted by FULL MOON (Moonbeam) on 10/27 at 20:49
Redbee, I agree with you, a little manners in the game goes a long ways, and seems to be a little short with some people. It should be up to the winner of the game to chose to rechallenge the other player.
         
 Re: rematch Message #17352    Replies: 0
posted by paully (Paul) on 10/28 at 00:54
I like Will's method that he posts on his profile about the loser will rechallenge. Sometimes a winner rechallenging can be interpretted by the losing player as being pushed into another match. If the loser rechallenges, then I feel more good will is created
     
 Re: rematch Message #17353    Replies: 1
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 10/28 at 04:20
Really? That ends up feeling like one of those social obligations that can get out of hand. Like sending a thank you card in reply to a thank you card.

I have people I play on a regular basis. Either IRL friends or PM friends. But periodically I pick someone at random and send an invite. It keeps things fresh, you meet people you wouldn't otherwise. But that doesn't mean I necessarily want to keep playing them.

Will has a good model, where if he loses a game -- and wants to keep playing -- he sends an invite. Otherwise he feels it is up to the loser, if they want to.
       
 Re: rematch Message #17358    Replies: 0
posted by Redbee (Lori) on 10/28 at 15:55
I totally agree with you Jock, I love meeting new people but they arent always the nicest or friendliest...so may not want to play them again.

And, Amen, Fullmoon, a little common courtesy does go a LONG way...to a new or old friend.

But i stick to my ground that it should just be up to either player, win or lose, if they care to send a new invite out. Some people i play with will only play if they invite cause they want to be the white player, either way works with me. Sometimes its just a matter of who sends the new invite first not win or lose...and thats the way it should be. If i played someone and won and didnt send an invite its not that i dont necessarily want to play them again, but more that either i didnt realize we didnt have a game going or just hadnt gotten around to it yet.

Forum software by Crowder Software
Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.