Pocket-Monkey(tm) Discussion Forum

[Home] | [The Catchall Cafe] | A book for everyone's taste[Forum Rules] [Login]

A book for everyone's taste

Thread #1777 - Messages: 30   (some may be hidden) **This thread is closed** 
 A book for everyone's taste Message #18070    Replies: 6
posted by Silverwalker (Silverwalker) on 12/15 at 14:53
Which novel do you think everyone could appreciate?

My guess would be Call of the Wild, by Jack London.
 
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18071    Replies: 1
posted by moonstone (Caroline Bryson-Peart) on 12/15 at 15:26
remember that one .. agreed
   
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18091    Replies: 0
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 12/17 at 03:24
Alice In Wonderland
 
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18733    Replies: 1
posted by NancyL (Nancy) on 02/08 at 04:39
VERY late to add 2 cents but my vote would be "Where the Red Fern Grows". :D
   
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18734    Replies: 1
posted by judybell (judy s :O)) on 02/08 at 07:42
twilight books are good
     
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18737    Replies: 1
posted by dalyark (dalya) on 02/08 at 18:09
books that has pictures in it- hey I am from Arkansas :)
       
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18743    Replies: 1
posted by Redbee (Lori) on 02/08 at 20:18
Gone With the Wind
         
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18747    Replies: 1
posted by FULL MOON (Moonbeam) on 02/08 at 22:36
Bambi
           
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18752    Replies: 0
posted by judybell (judy s :O)) on 02/09 at 00:49
dear john
 
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18753    Replies: 1
posted by ironmanmv (marc) on 02/09 at 00:59
see spot run
   
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18755    Replies: 0
posted by tjrm (Jim) on 02/09 at 04:09
Jonathan Livingston Seagull; and
The Little Prince (Le Petit Prince)
 
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18778    Replies: 2
posted by ironmanmv (marc) on 02/09 at 23:22
i just heard in the news they want to rewrite the ethnic thing out of huck finn so its more suitable in school.
what a sad state our world is in when Mark Twain books need to be edited.
Wonder if the bullfrog race story is animal abuse?
   
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18786    Replies: 0
posted by paully (Paul) on 02/10 at 10:47
doesnt even the Bible get edited and reqritten every so often due to changing times?
   
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18787    Replies: 4
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/10 at 12:13
As is usually the case, the soundbite doesn't do the story justice. :-)

Yes, there is a publisher who is doing a small run (7,500 copies initially) of a version of Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn in which the N word, which has a different meaning and connotation now than it did then, is replaced with the word "slave". (Similarly "Injun Joe" becomes "Indian Joe" and "half-breed" becomes "half-blood".) There is a specific, carefully considered, thoughtful reason for doing this, but you won't get that from the inflammatory headlines people circulate (not Marc; but just do a search and see what turns up).

This came about as the result of the experiences of a preeminent Twain scholar who has spent 40 years studying and teaching Twain. He's doing this in direct response to hearing from teachers, time and again, that they can't teach the books in their schools specifically because of these words.

The edition will have a clear preface explaining what's been done, and why. By creating the edition, his goal is to get Twain -- and the central, anti-bigotry message of the novels -- in front of students who would otherwise not be exposed to them at all.

Is it the right thing to do? This isn't the place to debate that question, and don't read the above as an endorsement. I just wanted to give the fuller picture.

More in this blog entry from the Telegraph.

-- T.J.
     
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18801    Replies: 0
posted by judybell (judy s :O)) on 02/10 at 17:42
it is crazy ppl wants to rewrite history...we grew up with all them books n ppl didnt say anything then...the world is going crazy
     
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18803    Replies: 1
posted by ladybabyjane (Lady) on 02/10 at 17:43
Thank you TJ for putting, yet again, things into perspective!
       
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18809    Replies: 0
posted by Play Misty (Sue) on 02/10 at 23:44
Well my fav book as a child was Riccki-ticcie-tarvie.
you must excuse my spelling of the title as im a lot....and i mean A LOT older now,LOL
but i know i've spelt it wrong.
it's about a mongoose....fabulous!
     
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18810    Replies: 1
posted by jockm (Jock Murphy) on 02/10 at 23:46
The big problem I have with this edition is that the book is set almost two decades after slavery was abolished in the US. So the choice of slave is very odd, and misinforming.

I can think of a lot better choices of words (to me at least) than the ones the editor chose, ones that would fit better, while still achieving the goal.

However I have problems with the goal. Even in 1884 the book was deliberately controversial. Twain meant it to be provoking in both subject matter and language. So changing the language in such a way also changes the intent; and that is deeply problematic.


       
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18819    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/11 at 05:36
Yes, it's deeply fraught with peril, although I think in terms of the actual replacement word, a 40-year Twain scholar probably knows that the book was set well after slavery and researched the appropriate language to use. (Whether any change was appropriate is another matter.)

But again, this isn't the place to discuss it, not least because we're hijacking Silverwalker's book thread.

But I for one am off to read Twain! Thanks Marc!

-- T.J. :-)
     
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18892    Replies: 1
posted by Silverwalker (Silverwalker) on 02/15 at 20:16
>There is a specific, carefully considered, thoughtful reason for doing this, but you won't get that from the inflammatory headlines people circulate (not Marc; but just do a search and see what turns up).
>
>This came about as the result of the experiences of a preeminent Twain scholar who has spent 40 years studying and teaching Twain. He's doing this in direct response to hearing from teachers, time and again, that they can't teach the books in their schools specifically because of these words.


I have a specific, carefully considered, thoughtful reason to let Mark Twain's book remain uncensored by the Politically Correct cabal that dominates the major media and the social studies at universities. Regarding "scholars," they are paid to write material that can be used for political purposes. The truth is their enemy.

"They can't teach the books" -- really? Of course they can. But they are leftists who don't WANT to present anything other than an edited, false version of history.

This is reminiscent of the carefully constructed picture of the first Indians (not "Native Americans," America wasn't even built yet) the Pilgrims encountered. Peace-loving and living in harmony with nature. But the truth is, no people was peace-loving back in history; a major genocidal war had depopulated much of the north-east, and some Indians allied with the Pilgrims in order to gain allies against enemy tribes. That's the way things have always worked. A much more enlightening, educational view of the world than what teachers present in schools -- people need to learn about reality. For this reason, Mark Twain's book should not be censored, and neither should any other part of classic literature, or history, or any field of study.
       
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18893    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/15 at 20:49
Again: This is not the place to discuss this stuff.

All: No replies to Silverwalker's post, please. We'll leave it there.

-- T.J.
 
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18820    Replies: 1
posted by gogdog (pete john) on 02/11 at 07:29
The Wasp factory..Iain Banks
   
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18894    Replies: 0
posted by Play Misty (Sue) on 02/15 at 21:13
The Watchers...Stephen King.

a book that shows true love between us humans & an animal...a Dog,lovely book ;)
 
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18896    Replies: 1
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/15 at 21:31
A book for everyone's taste is a tall order.

Some that come to mind:

The Time Traveller's Wife by Audrey Niffenegger (yes, recently made into a film -- haven't seen the film yet, wondering how they approached it). Great story, well told, and surprising.

The Dead Zone by Stephen King. A surprising mix of a love story, a story of friendship, the supernatural, grand scope, and tragedy.

Rat Race, Flying Finish, and Dead Cert by Dick Francis. Yes, they're mass-market mystery, but in his earlier books, he was much better at it than most.

I really need to find more time to read.

-- T.J. ;-)
   
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18897    Replies: 1
posted by Play Misty (Sue) on 02/15 at 22:40
its your fault we all dont read more TJ? LOL for having a great site that keeps us up too late to read in bed,;)
     
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18919    Replies: 1
posted by judybell (judy s :O)) on 02/17 at 20:11
i'm reading family tree
       
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18920    Replies: 1
posted by FULL MOON (Moonbeam) on 02/17 at 21:42
Uncle Tom's Cabin
         
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18922    Replies: 1
posted by theloneranger (CHRIS) on 02/17 at 23:26
I'm reading this discussion????
           
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18923    Replies: 1
posted by Play Misty (Sue) on 02/17 at 23:27
it all went to pot some how & went off favorite books?
             
 Re: A book for everyone's taste Message #18926    Replies: 0
posted by T.J. (T.J. Crowder) on 02/18 at 08:01
We're back there now.

-- T.J.

Forum software by Crowder Software
Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.