posted by RedBaron (Will C. Crowder) on 06/17 at 05:21
Hey folks,
Let's have a discussion about the use of computer aid in playing on-line games.
There are, of course, many excellent programs to play virtually every game available on this site. This includes especially the biggies like backgammon, chess, etc. Also, many games on the site have been "solved," that is, the game is such that it is possible to predict the outcome based on who moves first, assuming every move is made correctly. For such games computer programs exist which move correctly every time. (If you're curious, type "<name of game> solved" into a Google search. Some examples are Gomuku, Mill, Tic-Tac-Toe [obviously], etc.)
Obviously, the use of any such software in playing an on-line game would be cheating, big time. I'm guessing we can all agree on that, but who knows... :-)
There are some gray ares, though, and I've encountered one: I was a software engineer for many years (I'm retired from it now) and I still tinker. As a match backgammon player, I'm of course very interested in understanding the odds in various situations.
I wrote a program which computes the odds of pure-race situations. Understanding such odds is important in making doubling decisions, both offering and answering, in matches. (For other SEs out there: the method is pure brute force Monte Carlo...nothing fancy, I'm afraid.)
Obviously, use of this program to make a doubling decision would be cheating, and I've never done it. The gray area arises from something I have done, but which I will no longer do: I have used the program to evaluate the correctness of an already-made decision. My reasoning was that doing so didn't really give me any immediately useful information, although it did help educate me about the game. Using software to improve your game is certainly allowable. But I've concluded that I can only do that after the game has ended, just in case there's redoubling involved (which happens very rarely, to me anyway).
So my conclusions are that, obviously, use of software to make game decisions is cheating. In fact, the use of software to gain information about a game-in-progress, even seemingly benign "immediate post mortem" analysis, as in my case above, is also not allowable. However, analysis after-the-fact of a real-world game is fine, as is any use of software to help improve your game, either through analysis or by providing a strong opponent to play against.
I've had the urge to express some views on this topic for a long time, -- a consequence of reading the seemingly endless stream of complaints at a site where I played correspondence-style chess (i.e. where consulting books is expected).
I truly don't care what my opponents do! Perhaps most others don't feel the same way; but there are probably more than a few who share my outlook, but don't respond to the complaints because it would sound like they were rationalizing their own cheating.
Some of us don't play for prizes, awards or ratings. We play mostly as a relaxing pass-time, which usually includes at least a smattering of chat. Though, we prefer winning to losing, and know that opponents using software would raise our losing percentages, it would take a whole lot of cheating to materially affect our enjoyment.
I can imagine cases where I would welcome such activity. For example, I played correspondence-style chess fairly seriously -- as a student of the game. I enjoyed the games I lost quite as much as any I won -- because either way there was a move or sequence of moves to add to my database and analysis of the lines that I found interesting. I often sought games against players who were nearly certain to beat me -- not to test myself, but to test and expand my analyses.
In the present case, I would be happy if Will used his software against me while we played, and especially happy if he shared the output with me.
Jim
Re: Re: Use of computer aid
Message #1283 Replies: 1
posted by RedBaron (Will C. Crowder) on 06/18 at 16:09
tjrm (Jim) wrote:
I truly don't care what my opponents do! Perhaps most others don't feel the same way; but there are probably more than a few who share my outlook, but don't respond to the complaints because it would sound like they were rationalizing their own cheating.
Well, I'm also here to play as a relaxing pass-time and also as an intellectual challenge...I will admit that, if my ratings were higher, I'd be proud of them. :-) Anyway, I would prefer to know if I'm playing a human or a computer, so I do consider the undisclosed use of software to make game decisions to be cheating. But if someone wants to invite me and say, "Hey, I got this great new backgammon program...Want to see how you do against it?" I'm likely to say, "Sure!"
In the present case, I would be happy if Will used his software against me while we played, and especially happy if he shared the output with me.
Well, this particular little one-off program I was talking about is nothing to write home about...I doubt that it bears off optimally, but it probably does give a good idea of the odds. There are some extremely sophisticated backgammon analysis programs available which would do a much better job. Anyway, if an appropriate situation arises in our games, I'm happy to do and share the "immedate post mortem" analysis...
A fair and reasonable addition! Disclose the use in any event. Promise to share the output and your own thoughts, and you've got a willing victim here!
Will raises some interesting points. I personally don't like to use software to examine a game until after it is over, but will admit that I have made exceptions. Sometimes something unusual happens and you just want to replay it and understand why, and much like waiting to open presents at xMas, it can be hard to wait (even though you know you should).
--Jock
Re: Re: Use of computer aid
Message #1284 Replies: 1
posted by RedBaron (Will C. Crowder) on 06/18 at 16:10
jockm (Jock Murphy) wrote:
[...] and much like waiting to open presents at xMas, it can be hard to wait (even though you know you should).
Yup, that's for sure! :-)
Will aka The Baron :-)
Re: Re: Re: Use of computer aid
Message #1287 Replies: 1
posted by goofball38 (goofball38) on 06/19 at 00:49
I play to come online and just chill after a long day. I don't get heavily involved in games and most of my opponents feel the same way. I love this site because people are so laid back. If someone is using a program to play and its obvious (depending on the game) I will just resign. Otherwise I just play as I always do and just make a mental note not to play that person again. Then I pass it along to my friends who I play on this site to let them know. I'm not a very competitve person and just like to come here and play a leisurly game or two. But I do like to get into heavy discussion and love the idea about making the forums more active. I would, for one, participate.
I play for fun and dont mind losing to another player if they played better than me but if they were using a computer program then I would feel cheated out of a possible victory. I do not mind players reviewing the game using software because this is after the game has ended and they therefore cannot change the outcome, except maybe in future games in which the exact same board setup in encountered...which is very unlikely to happen.
Speaking personally (e.g., with my Pocket-Monkey administrator hat off)...
Perhaps because we were raised by the same parents (The Baron ain't heavy, he's my brother), I agree with Will that using his doubling-analysis tool to make a specific decision in a game would be inappropriate. I'd also say that using it after-the-fact for education is absolutely fine.
I don't like to do anything when playing online that I wouldn't do with my opponent sitting across from me at a table. So that means I don't go over to my bookcase and get down my copy of the Backgammon Handbook or 501 Backgammon Problems. I certainly don't run any analysis tools. [ A lot of sites expressly forbid the use of such tools -- while simultaneously admitting they'd be hard-pressed to prove someone was using them. :-) ]
That said, we're not sitting across the table from our opponents, and where's the line? If I'm in the middle of a match (as I always am), does that mean I can't kick back in the evening and study my Robertie books? Obviously not. And I have been known on occasion, in a tense Mill endgame, to sketch out various scenarios to get a feel for the situation, which I probably wouldn't do if my opponent were across from me. I understand it's fairly normal in play-by-mail Chess to have a board set up and to use it to do "what if" scenarios before making your real move.
I suspect the culture is slightly different with Chess than with Backgammon, not least because Chess is a purely strategic and tactical game whereas Backgammon has the additional element of statistical probability: Stats can be tricky, so software aids can give someone the edge (albeit only over entry- and mid-level players; players like heartsvertigo know this stuff cold anyway from their study of the game). I bet the culture varies a bit with other games as well, and I wouldn't be surprised to find regional differences, either.
I guess for me the bottom line is not to do anything you feel like you're "getting away with." But that's not too different from life in general, eh? ;-) Or to put it another way, if you're using something that markedly elevates your game beyond what you could do without it, well, that's probably not a great thing to do.
Hello,.. very interesting and good points in the above items,.. it has been frustating playing higher level checkers (yes there is such a thing lol) with all the programs out there,.. in another popular game site,. it was discovered there were 4 players using many nic names and 2 very good computer programs to top the rankings.. so say out of the top 60 players,.. 30 were really fake,.. thus ratings were untrue for those of us that like to see where we place.. one of the reasons i came to this site, for the more laid back play and less stress... i did note one benifit to the programs,.. it improved my play somewhat,. as well there is a asite (many other i sure) where one can play directly against the programs and see if one can draw or beat it.. kinda a nice challenge sometimes.. i play on scrabble type site and most people on that site are divided over program assisted play and / or use of descramblers and dictionaries,.. i say maybe divide the gaming into divisions of extremely competitive,. and recreational... might work in game sites as it does for some sports leagues ??
When it comes to Scrabble, I try to play on my own. However, when I cannot think of any words on my own and the letters do not seem to spell anything, I might possibly use such a program. When I can finally see words again, I turn it off and resume as usual. This is especially helpful for those that have less intelligence or a smaller vocabulary.
i say as long as both players are in agreement and aware what the other considers fair,.. in my profile on scrabble site i indicate i use dictionaries etc,.. and i expect the same of my other,.. if they ask for melo fun game we both turn of dictionary.. as long as games fair and fun.. the aides are good... when the aides creates an unfair playing field,.. it hurts and becomes less fun
another way to confirm if they use program or not is to invite them to live fast game on another site (although these sites are far less fun that PM !! ) where programs cant keep up and then see what they made of,..
tarzan
Re: Re: Re: Re: Use of computer aid
Message #1590 Replies: 0
posted by walchung (walchung-retired cop) on 10/30 at 05:07
Using any de-scrambler in Scrabble is cheating. Period. I've stopped playing with someone I knew was using one. If you want to expand your vocabulary, work crossword puzzles.
Forum
software by
Crowder Software Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.