I just wanted to post that I am frustrated that IYT is down, and seems to be down on a continual basis. I like the site, but am losing patience with it, and wonder if my dollars might be better spent elsewhere. They are the only turn-based site I've found that has Jamble, or any Scrabble variant. I respect Patrick Chu and all, I just needed a place to vent. Thank you for letting me do so.
I am a IYT member and have found myself here on POCKET-MONKEY as a result of IYT being down..yet again. Like you I enjoy the IYT site and have grown accustomed to it. However, also like you I am getting increasingly impatient with their site not functioning, slow access and refreshes, and just plain failure to play at any given time I want to play. While I may respect Patrick Chu in the sense that he put together a nice site this recent outage has left me questoining just how much I do respect him. His statement when the site first went down about refunds seemed well thought out and resonable. However a later posting by him made it apparent that his original notice was not all that well thoguht out after all. I also question the wisdom of not apparently having an off line tape backup system in place. It may be old technology, but for reliability a tape system can not be beat.
Re: Re: Does anyone here play at It's Your Turn?
Message #1382 Replies: 0
posted by daisyheadmaisy (daisyheadmaisy) on 08/21 at 03:08
I too am an IYT member, and am dissapointed, again, that the site is down.
I really feel for the ItsYourTurn folks -- both the members who can't play their games, and Pat Chu and his team. As an administrator of a game site, I can tell you that this is the nightmare scenario, the thing that gives you the cold sweats. I wish Pat and his team the best in their recovery efforts and I'm sure they'll be up and running again very soon. -- T.J. Crowder First Primate Pocket-Monkey.com
Re: Re: Does anyone here play at It's Your Turn?
Message #1395 Replies: 1
posted by daisyheadmaisy (daisyheadmaisy) on 08/23 at 21:56
T.J. - I am in no way busting Pat and team. I too appreciate the stress that they must be under. I am however dissapointed that the site is down. I stopped playing here because my pages wouldn't open and it was very frustrating. It was an issue on my end. Things are fine now, and I appreciate being able to get a few games in on your site. Thanks T.J.
Re: Re: Re: Does anyone here play at It's Your Turn?
Didn't mean to imply you were! (My message in the thread just happened to come right below yours.) Glad to have you back!
-- T.J. :-)
Re: Does anyone here play at It's Your Turn?
Message #1471 Replies: 0
posted by Gma Bobbye (Bobbye Kuhlman) on 08/31 at 23:18
I played IYT for a couiple weeks, then paid the years fee about a week before they went down. I checked daily and read all the sweet words about being up and running,---but---then they finally came back on, and low and behold, my membership was cancelled, and they have not repoded to the notes I have sent every day this week, since they came back iup. Frustration -:>{ . Now, they have cut the freebie game moves to 15 a day, and have not had the courtesy to answer my mails.Anyone having similar problems? I am 72 on SSI, and cannot afford to pay again. Any suggestions? Gma Bobbye from Traverse City, MI
I have played on IYT from 1989 when I frist got PC, frist game site I found, Have played on a lot of game sites, and IYT and Pogo.com are the only sites I do pay on now. Have been with Pogo for years too. and I have found that all game sites have down time. Pay or free. I have 2 paid IDs on IYT I love all the games there and all the tournaments. and will stay a paid member till I find a site that has all that on it IYT for the same money.I do think for what you pay at IYT you get your money back with a lot of fun and I have got to know a lot of nice players there. But Pat needs to keep it up a little better. I think we have all learned from his mess this time . I am now backing up my PCs.(4) of them.
Re: Re: Re: IYT
Message #1442 Replies: 1
posted by daisyheadmaisy (daisyheadmaisy) on 08/29 at 23:39
The site is up and running. I have however found that I really enjoy playing here. Glad to have met so many new people.
I play on IYT myself, though I decided to get myself signed up here on PM. Mostly because I'm fed up by the limits of IYT and I feel its ridiculous to pay for a membership. Here are the annoying limits...
15 moves per day. 2 posts in their forums a day. 20 games limit. Non-members have some rather severe tournament limits. There are certain games a non-member isn't allowed to play. Certain tournaments aren't allowed for non-members. Whenever there's an outage, little compensation is made. Whenever there's a complaint, its not handled.
Pat Chu seemed like a nice guy, at first. Later on, it was obvious he was only after the money his site would generate. He wasn't really somebody that was trying to put on a free website that would contribute to people's lives. I've even offered to be on his staff, for no pay, just to help people out. He's refused. He doesn't want anyone to help him out. He once remarked that once the problems are bad enough, people would want to start paying him for better quality gameplaying. >_<; In short, I don't like him.
I won't comment on how IYT does them, but I think paid memberships as a concept are reasonable -- in fact, we'll probably have paid memberships of some kind here at Pocket-Monkey at some point. We won't be able to continue to provide Pocket-Monkey entirely for free forever. The advertising on the site doesn't come close to paying even just the equipment and bandwidth costs, much less personnel time. (I'm not complaining, mind -- we wouldn't run Pocket-Monkey if we didn't love doing it.) There are things we want to have in place before we do anything like that (like tournaments, which aren't that far away, and some other things), and we're still looking at exactly how we'll approach it, but we will at some point need to have the site paying for itself.
I should hasten to add that there will always be some kind of free access to Pocket-Monkey; we've always been committed to that. But if we do go the route of paid memberships, free access will have to have some limits on it.
Of course, if we charge, we'll make certain that paid members are getting a fair deal. That means not charging people if the site is unavailable for some reason at our end, and of course answering support questions in a timely, accurate, and helpful way. I'd like to think we already do that last bit, but then, I would. ;-)
I'll post a more complete announcement if/when we get closer to charging. -- T.J. Crowder First Primate Pocket-Monkey.com
O.O At some point you're going to make free memberships limited? >_<; Great. Just lovely. You're the nicest people I've met, and now you're talking about doing the same rude poo I've had to deal with at IYT! I had hoped you were different. You have a decent selection of games with only a few more needed. Yeesh...
I swear, people are UNABLE to ban the temptation of money from their business. I'd like to see someone be brave enough to ban it from their business and run the business because of pure dedication to offering people and disadvantaged individuals the chance to enjoy something that they don't have to be harassed to pay for.
I am no longer at ITY not because of having to pay for the membership but lack of support from Patrick- I enjoy playing here for free- but when you do go to paid memberships I will be glad to pay- because of all of the nice people playing here including TJ, Wendy and Jock- This is a better site than ITY.
With all due respect, it takes more money than most people are willing to spend to maintain a site like this, and an even greater investment in time. The ads you see cover a fraction of those costs, but up until such time that PM does charge for memberships or has some other revenue generating system it comes directly out of our pockets.
I understand what you are saying, but a business that doesn't generate any income isn't a business. It is a hobby. There is nothing wrong with that, and the majority of the turn-based sites out there turn little or no profit.
We have always tried to be upfront that at some point we were going to have some kind of subscriptions. We have never wanted to mislead people about that, and we have always said there would be some kind of free access to the site.
How this will be done and what form it will take, is mostly up to TJ (I am semi-retired from managing the site). What I can tell you is that we have always wanted to make the site self sustaining in a way that would have the least impact on our players.
Well... now you have my curiousity piqued. I appreciate your kindness as you explain how expensive this is. How much money are we talking here? If you're shy, then a rounded down figure can be given.
And what does all that sum pay for, exactly? You don't have to give exact brand names for the items on the list.
I was under the impression all it took was to have your own website, an internet connection, a website-building software that you purchase at some store, then you build it and there's nothing more to it other than technical support.
I offered to help IYT with any assistance/technical issues/player issues/etc. so that they could have a staffmember that's not interested in wages. I honestly don't mind working for a site that needs the help and I don't need to be paid for it. IYT refused me. Would you be interested in that kind of help or beyond?
I am not going to give exact figures. But tell you what. Open your favorite browser and go to google and search for "dedicated linux server." Don't pick the cheapest one and don't pick the most expensive. Then order two of them. Then there are some minor charges for the online store, and domain name, and misc things like that. There are digits and there are between 4 and 5 of them. I am afraid those are all the details I am comfortable revealing. TJ can expand as he sees fit.
Sure you can make a bunch of web pages with off the shelf software, but that doesn't give you the games. The very first prototype of the site that did nothing other than let you sign on and play a crude version of reversi took 200 hours to write. I dedicated between 20-50 hours a week for the next 5 months before I launched the site to the general public, and is was a fraction of what you see here. After that (when I got back to having a day job) I put in about 15 hours a week supporting and an enhanching the site.
Now as to your generous offer of help. I thank you for it, and I know TJ thanks you for it. It an amazing and wonderful thing you want to do. It is up to TJ to decide if he will accept it. However let me give you some of the reasons why I might have declined it while I was Chief Monkey:
Free isn't free. Even if you pay no money directly for something (like salery), free is never free. You pay something, even if it isn't money (for example liability)
Loss of control. Small technology businesses work because there are is a tight team that knows how to work together and share the same vision. Each person you add means you give up some of that control (this is both a good and a bad thing), and you need to pick the people you add very very carefully.
Loss of time. It would take a fair amount of training to get someone in a position to help support the site. And beyond that there is the time to supervise. So for the first few months it could easily take more time to train and supervise the right person, than I might have spent doing it myself.
Front line support isn't where most of my time went. Programming, debugging, and researching complicated player problems. So in the end it wouldn't save as much as you think, and it would just free some more time to work on the site, not compensate for the out of pocket costs at all.
These are a handful of the reasons I might have turned down such an offer. Things change, and TJ might (or might not) have other reasons for accepting it. As I said, it is up to him.
But let us get back to subscription fees. I know the $30/year IYT charges can be a lot, but it isn't that much really. Compare it to a magazine (or newspaper) subscription. THen consider how much you get for what you are spending. Compare it to going to a matinee 5 times in one year. It breaks down to 8 cents per day (a tiny bit more, but I am rounding).
Assume you are on the site for 15 minutes a day (which is low for most people), and you play on the site 4 days a week (which is low for most people). Then you are getting 52 hours of game playing for about a third of a dollar per hour. And if you played as little as I mention then with a couple of exceptions you would be fine with what is covered by the average free account.
We are going to disagree on this, but I see nothing wrong as operating as a business that expects to recoup its losses, and to even make a profit. It would be possible and even interesting to see a game site that was run by volunteers and paid for though donations. But so far there hasn't been one.
And really I don't think there is much more to say on the matter. Especially now that I seem to have written a small novel disguised as a forum post :)
Wow. Well, my offer's still up, but I thank you for the explanation. It's such a beautifully detailed one too. It does help me expand my dense mind, especially about how the makings of a gaming site is done.
I probably misinterpreted how well a site could be made and handled with only one person, considering Patrick Chu's story [IYT]. He's done it all. So I thought it would be easy and cheap. There have been people, at any point in history, that could do something that was otherwise challenging.
As for this site, it's very good and I do enjoy it. Sure, we may disagree on business stuff, but that's only because I'm a very old-fashioned and idealistic person. Go figure, I want to take what's hard about the world and life and remove it, make the world have a bit of utopia and life become less of a grief. I try in many ways, and just about in that many ways, I get rejected. Oh well.
Thank you for answering my questions and enlightening me. Perhaps you are the Buddha of the Gaming World but my mind is too small to comprehend your wisdom. I praise your work and your devotion to something like this. Have a good day.
Mina --Pocket Chimp [hoo ha ha]
Forum
software by
Crowder Software Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.