Would it be possible to see who the top player is overall on this site? Many players can't reach the top of any one game, but overall, could very well be the best player.
Possible solution could be:
Take the players top X game ratings (say 10), average them, and that is their overall rating. Something like that could be done, and I am sure there are players who would top 1800 for their overall rating. In fact I have seen players that in their profile have consistent 1750 and above for all of their games, yet this individual was not at the top of any one game standings.
This would cause players to become more competitive in all of their games and for the drive of moving up that standings as well could cause players to play more. Which means more traffic flow... which can be a very good... you know what I mean... yeah, so good idea I think! should be fairly simple to put into the system as well!
((ELO Rating of game 1) - 1600) + ((ELO Rating of game type 2) - 1600) + etc...
This allows for the rating of each type of game to factor in. If people have not played a certain type of game, than obviously their score for that ELO rating is 1600, which causes 0 to be the number included in the overall rating.
I thought of this because using the top X ELO ratings for one person is going to cause different scores for each person because my top X ELO ratings are different than the next persons top X ELO ratings.
We've never considered doing that, just because it inevitably means comparing apples and oranges (e.g., ratings in different games). But I'm not saying it's a bad idea at all. I like your second way of doing it -- evaluate it in terms of deviation from the starting point.
I'll put it on the long-term list of things to consider. Thanks!! -- T.J. Crowder First Primate Pocket-Monkey.com
That is exactly why I thought the first version would not work. I realized that when I considered posts that you had written about why ELO ratings from other sites can't be implemented on this site. Same thing for reversi to backgammon or whatever. So, I wanted to revise it and did so with my second version.
Forum
software by
Crowder Software Pocket-Monkey and the Pocket-Monkey logo are trademarks of T.J. Crowder and Jock Murphy. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.